My NFL Forums | NFL Forums & Blogs

While contemplating the utter futility displayed by our franchise QB it made me wonder where JR fits on the list of other useless QB's we've seen. I prolly missed some, but am interested to see where my Raider Brethren rank JR in comparison with the other schmucks.

Marc Wilson and Jay Schroeder atleast went to the playoffs as Raider Qbs The others please were just bad i still have to take J-Burger first and Marinovich second Vince Evans was just a back up that came in during the 87 scab season i believe that was the year

__________________
8-8 Again Really

Aaron Brooks was the worst because he did absolutely nothing for the Raiders.

__________________
PEACE RAIDER NATION!

What have the Flipping burger, eating sob done for the Raiders? But screw Al out of 60m.

Yeah, but JaBusted at least won a game. Aaron Brooks couldn't even do that.

__________________
PEACE RAIDER NATION!

Aaron Brooks did not Fuck Al out of 60m either....

i didnt like aaron brooks. but he tried. he gave a damn. russell doesnt care about any1 but himself. u see him throwing medacine balls. zach miller got a concussion. he got mcfadden SMACKED 2 weeks ago on a bad pass mcfadden tried to tip to himself. you never see russell going up to them later and apologizing... no russell got his money, and he dont care. and the best part. they show hackett on the sidelines showing russell things on paper and you see frye and gradkowski looking at it over russell and hackets shoulders, and you see russell stairing off into never never land the opposite direction. russell just does not care... brooks at least tried... brooks took N.O. to the playoffs. russell could not take any team to the playoffs...

__________________
once a fan, always a fan,
always in the thoughts.
raidacane!

Course of not. We were asked who was the worst QB for the Raiders and I simply stated that Aaron Brooks was the worst based on not winning a game.

__________________
PEACE RAIDER NATION!

Those are some tough choices. It sure as fuck ain't Scroeder though, I can tell you that.

Marinovich? Brooks? Russell?

It's one of those. Tough call. BUT:

Brooks had Moss.

Marinovich had Marcus, Timmy and Gault.

Since Russell has 2 rookie WRs starting and a very young team around him, the trophy goes to:

Andrew Walter was the worst starter we've ever had. 3 TDs 13 INTs. Can't beat that with a stick.

But of those listed it has to be Brooks.

.... shit vs. warmed-over shit. At the end of the day, it's all shit.