My NFL Forums | NFL Forums & Blogs

I know it sounds crazy, but dude is never on the goddamn field. He hasn't made it threw one season. I'm just wondering what we could get for him, cause we need some linebackers badly.. we need a MLB and a SLB like now.. and if we can get a couple of picks for him let's say a first and a third or fourth. The o-line is more important than the RB. I know some of those plays if mcfadden was in the game they would have been TD's, but to my point he is never healthy.

I'm not gonna call you crazy cause i was thinking the same thing today. I love Dmac but this thing with him getting injured every year is getting out of hand. Think about it for a moment Bush is a free agent the chance of him staying are slim and lets assume he does leave and Dmac gets hurt again next year then what.I will tell you we are FUCKED sounds crazy but if we can get some Monster picks for him i do it and sign Bush long term.

__________________
8-8 Again Really

Just say no. One should not trade a player like McFadden - period.

__________________

I agree also but Dmac gets hurt to much thats all i am saying

__________________
8-8 Again Really

That's the thing Bush is more than likely gone if not made a starter.... What good is a great player if he never plays or is good for 8-10 games a year and when you need him he's on the sideline.

I am on the fence about it because I could see it working out for us eithyer way if it's handled right.

If we dish McFadded we better damn well be sure we can lock Bush up long-term come FA time. Then we could snag a decent backup to him, maybe another draft pick (could even use one of the ones we get for McFadden), and run with that.

In the absence of a long-term deal with Bush, I would not let McFadden go anywhere.

i was saying the same thing last week to my buddy and he told me im nuts... but look at next year with no bush... if mcfadden goes down we have jones... dont get me wrong jones is good and all, but i dont want him carrying the load... id say trade mcfadden in the offseason for like a 2 and 3 round pix... that dont sound like much i know... but rb's only last a few seasons, hes always hurt... and a 2 n 3 help... and bush can be the bell cow with jones as the change of pace....

not only that... but jones is not really a change of pace to mcfadden... they are both cut and speed... whereas with mcfadden... we'd get better value... bush will sign longterm if hes THE GUY... i think he would... and jones behind bush is still thunder and lightning...

__________________
once a fan, always a fan,
always in the thoughts.
raidacane!

McFadden is the best running back on the team - he runs fast and he runs hard. He can catch and he can block - no way should the Raiders trade him. M. Bush is solid, but he does not give the Raiders what McFadden does. If the Raiders want to become an elite team, they should keep McFadden - if the goal is to be average or worse, trade him.

__________________

...when he's on the field.

There, that's really the only way you can complete that thought.

You motherfukas are crazy if you want to dump DMAC! He is a beast! Getting rid him would be shitty move like getting rid of Gruden, Woodson, Allen, etc was to the team!

__________________
www.790thsfs.com