My NFL Forums | NFL Forums & Blogs

New coach Mike Shanahan finally put his stamp on the Redskins' offense, trading for veteran quarterback Donovan McNabb to replace Jason Campbell in the NFL offseason's biggest move thus far.

Headed into his 12th season, McNabb remains a perfectly competent player and likely a significant upgrade from Campbell. But don't assume that the McNabb-Shanahan pairing suddenly will make for beautiful fantasy music. While McNabb should push the Redskins' passing game back into fantasy relevance (and he could keep winning), he will not be a top 10 fantasy quarterback.

Simply look at his history. McNabb has two seasons of at least 25 TD passes in his career, 25 in 2001 and 31 in 2004 with Terrell Owens. And 25 TD passes has become the new benchmark among fantasy QBs; 12 threw at least 26 last season. The rest of McNabb's seasons are a bunch of 19, 21, 22 TD years. Perfectly reasonable numbers, but hardly earth-shattering.

McNabb also will not have a great crew of receivers - not that he did very often in Philadelphia either. Santana Moss should enjoy having a competent thrower and could pile up a bunch of catches. Devin Thomas started to show some positive signs at the end of last season, while tight ends Chris Cooley and Fred Davis might be the happiest pair in this deal. McNabb made frequent, albeit inconsistent, use of his tight ends in Philadelphia, while Shanahan's offense also stresses the tight end.

Do not overlook McNabb's injury history, either. He has played 16 games once in the past five years. Although he tore an ACL in 2005, most of the injuries are relatively minor, but count on him missing at least a game or two. Plus, McNabb's relative inaccuracy could frustrate Shanahan. McNabb is a career 59% passer and completed 60.3% of his throws last year. In another time, that would be noteworthy. Last year, 60.3% was good for 20th in the league - and about 4% worse than Campbell.

At this point in his career, McNabb will not significantly change his stripes, regardless of his coach. Expect another season of TDs in the low 20s and interceptions around 10, and that is not going to change the dynamics of your league as much as it will the tone of the NFC East.

LINK

__________________